Maggie and Jack were childhood friends and now co-host a successful local radio show where they give dating advise. When they learn that their show is being considered for national syndication, their supervisor advises them to present their significant others to their families for a live, on-air New Year's Eve special. Maggie and Jack agree to the program on the condition that it is staged at their fathers' neighborhood jazz club, The Magnolia. However, when both Maggie and Jack are dumped prior to the big occasion, Jack recommends they pretend to be a couple and inform their listeners during a midnight kiss on New Year's Eve!