Holly a professor in a college that is small, has received a long history of choosing the guy. She's realized quite a little in her life, however after her younger sister declares she is pregnant, Holly decides she is going to make a bid to meet Mr. Right. Meanwhile, the another professor, David, is one dad, very bright and type, however, perhaps not the kind that Holly takes note of once the two are delegated to plan the Christmas Formal. At the insistence of the best friend, Holly signs up to your dating internet site"Cupid's Arrow," at which she meets Josh, an attorney only hired by the faculty. He has everything she wants on the surface, but has little to say beyond his work and very great appearances. Josh and David were room mates in college, so Josh recruits poetic messages to be written by David in a endeavor to acquire over Holly.